New York, 1948: The City That Made a Private Eye

New York had changed. Trouble had not.

In 1948, a New Yorker could walk down a busy avenue and see a city that appeared to have the future neatly sewn up. The war was over. Broadway was blazing. The department stores had plenty to sell, and everybody seemed to have an opinion about what came next.

But a city is not a suit. You cannot turn it inside out and expect all the stains to disappear.

For a returning serviceman, the change from wartime orders to civilian life could be a particularly awkward one. The streets were crowded with men making a fresh start, old hands protecting their territory, and people who preferred not to explain how they made their money. That mixture makes 1948 irresistible territory for a hard-boiled detective story.

A city where even the subway fare could start an argument

On July 1, 1948, New York’s subway fare rose from a nickel to a dime, ending more than four decades of five-cent rides. It was the sort of everyday change the entire city could understand, and resent. Ten cents was not a fortune. Having to surrender twice as much for the same trip felt like being pickpocketed by the turnstile.

At City Hall sat Mayor William O’Dwyer, whose term ran from 1946 to 1950. Yet the important thing about New York is not which name was printed on the mayor’s door. It is the extraordinary number of lives happening below that door: on sidewalks, at docks, in cramped apartments, in hotel bars and in offices where the telephone never seemed to bring good news.

Why the private eye belongs here

A private detective makes a useful guide to this world because he does not have the luxury of believing everyone. The woman asking for help may be frightened—or lying. The respectable businessman may be neither. The man in the expensive suit may have borrowed the money for it and forgotten to return it.

And a good private eye spends an unreasonable amount of time noticing things that other people have paid good money to conceal.

The best noir settings offer more than dark streets and cigarette smoke. They offer competing loyalties. Who does a man owe something to: the law, the person paying him, the people who once kept him alive, or whatever is left of his conscience?

Enter Mack Denver. Or, to begin with, Mike Delaney.

In Young Gun in New York, the opening novel of The Mack Denver Story, a young ex-Marine finds that civilian life has failed to supply an adequate instruction manual. He has survived a war, but New York is perfectly capable of finishing the job.

There are detectives, criminals, people who fall unhappily between the two, and a collection of beautiful complications who would make any sensible man change his address. Our hero is not always sensible. He has a quick mouth, a stubborn streak, and an unfortunate tendency to ask the question everyone else is hoping he will forget.

That is the kind of city New York can be in a detective novel: a place where a fellow goes looking for a fresh start and stumbles straight into somebody else’s dirty secret.

Start at the beginning

If you enjoy crime fiction with a 1940s setting, a little gallows humor, and a private investigator who could start an argument in an empty elevator, begin with Young Gun in New York. It is Book 1 of The Mack Denver Story—and the first of many occasions when keeping quiet might have been the wiser option.

Discover the novels and read the series in order: https://www.eddiemcboon.com/series